Why ‘Because It’s Always Been Done That Way’ isn’t good enough

Dept. of Useless Design
Some design features that have been practiced a long time I don’t mind using – IF they have a good reason. Like toe kicks on cabinets, for example. Your toes need a place to go when you’re standing close to a cabinet. Fine. I can live with that. I can even live with cabinets that have no toe kick & are just open underneath.
What really makes me crazy is the long standing tradition of a 4″ backsplash.
What is that? Did someone standing around just say, hey let’s plop this extra piece of material along the back of the counter for no reason? Did they not care that they were consuming almost an inch of countertop real estate? Were they partners in crime with the same people who invented wallpaper?
Does not exist.
I have news, people. Splashes – as in water – are going to go where they damn well want to. There is no invisible barrier at that 4″ mark above the counter which magically prevents any splatter above it.
If the logic is to use an unnecessarily large piece of material to close the gap between the countertop & the wall, then it serves that purpose well. But it’s a waste of material, a dated aesthetic, and there are better ways to seal the joint.
Simple is good.
- First, scribe the countertop to the wall against which it butts for an exact fit to any irregularities in the wall surface. If your contractor can’t do that, fire them immediately & get a competent one.
- Second, caulk is our friend. It seals gaps. Which should be minimal if you didn’t have to fire your contractor.
- Third, treat the whole wall that the countertop butts cleanly to as the backsplash. Run *that* material down to the countertop surface.
Viola. Now you have the sealant at the wall, plus you have the backsplash material down to the countertop and another sealant at that joint.
And it doesn’t look like crapwork from 1973.





[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Becky Shankle, Paul Anater and Building Moxie, Lisa La Nasa. Lisa La Nasa said: RT @ecomod: Confession: I have no love for a 4" backsplash. http://bit.ly/hawkJF [...]
Becky,
thank you! I have been saying the same thing for years! I hate those tacky 4″ backsplashes!
Brenda Lynn
I agree with the backsplash idea, your description is much cleaner. However, it seems it takes an act of Congress to do anything but a backsplash with most clients or cabinet fabricators.
I’ve been tempted to put on the front page of my drawings if anyone says “because it’s always been done that way” they will be fired immediately. We are working with a culture that is in great need of education. However, it is beginning to tire me out.